Blog

Dark Patterns in digital design: a business risk you can't ignore

Written by Heather Cutenar | Nov 16, 2026, 10:52:39 AM

Dark patterns are deceptive design choices that manipulate users into taking actions they might not otherwise choose. These tactics prioritise business interests over user autonomy, making it harder for individuals to make informed decisions. Regulators, including the ICO, are increasingly focusing on these unethical practices, particularly in areas like cookie consent.

In this article, I’ll unpack the different types of dark patterns, from subtle nudges and default settings to more overt tactics like confirm shaming and consent bundling. By going through these examples, I’ll highlight how these practices can erode trust and compromise user autonomy. We’ll also explore the latest regulatory developments, with a particular focus on guidance and enforcement examples from the ICO, and provide practical advice for businesses on how to design more ethical and transparent user experiences.

 

Common Dark Patterns to Watch Out For  

 

 1. Bundled Consent & Biased Consent 

In these patterns, Users are forced to agree to multiple terms at once, often without a clear way to opt out of specific elements. Biased consent subtly nudges users toward a preferred choice by making alternatives less appealing, while bundling consent into a single action removes meaningful choice, making users to agree to multiple terms without clarity of what they are agreeing to.

When combined with biased consent framing, like suggesting that declining cookies will reduce functionality, it pressures users into complying with what you want them to. These design tactics may seem subtle, but they undermine user autonomy and violate the need for informed consent. 

 


 2. Harmful Nudges & Sludge 

Websites and apps may use nudges to push users toward decisions they wouldn’t normally make or introduce unnecessary friction (a.k.a. "sludge") to discourage certain actions, such as making it hard to cancel a subscription. 

  

If businesses can design seamless experiences to take users’ money, they should be equally capable of making cancellation just as simple as sign-up, not intentionally harder. Yet some businesses rely on tactics like burying cancel buttons deep within settings menus, requiring users to call customer service or even introducing time delays and guilt-tripping language to discourage cancellation.

These strategies are not just inconvenient, they’re a breach of user trust. Design should empower, not trap and shame people. Creating interfaces that respect user autonomy and make all choices - especially the difficult ones clear and accessible, businesses can build longer-term loyalty rather than short-term gains through manipulation.

 

3. Biased Framing & Confirm Shaming 

The way options are presented can influence decision-making. Biased framing makes one choice seem superior or more appealing even if the alternatives are equally valid, while confirm shaming uses emotionally manipulative language to push users into agreeing with a decision. 

  

In this example, the “No” option is deliberately framed to make users feel foolish or guilty for declining as no one wants to waste their money. The biased framing however subtly pressures users toward the “Yes” option as it’s the only option with colour – a bright colour at that - making users drawn to it. Both together compromises users ability to make a free and informed decision:

  • It manipulates user emotions rather than supporting a well thought-out choice.
  • It erodes trust in the brand.
  • It can lead to consent fatigue or decisions users later regret.

 

4.  Default Settings 

  

Many users stick with default settings, making pre-selected options a powerful technique with which to influence them. Businesses often exploit this by setting defaults that favour their own interests, such as automatically opting users into data sharing or promotional emails. Default settings can create a false sense of user choice, when in reality, the decision has already been subtly made for them. The practice therefore:

  • undermines informed consent, as users may not realise they’ve agreed to additional terms.
  • prioritises business gain over user autonomy
  • can erode trust if users later discover they’ve been opted into settings they didn’t explicitly choose.
 

 

Regulatory Focus

 

Regulatory bodies are increasingly prioritising enforcement against deceptive user experience (UX) practices. In the UK, the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) has made clear that businesses must ensure their design choices comply with legal standards and do not mislead or manipulate users.

  • The ICO has emphasised that consent and user choice must be fair, transparent and free from manipulation – a point echoed in its guidance on dark-pattern design. It has highlighted dark-patterns and manipulative design choices (e.g. in cookie banners) as high-risk focus areas.

  • India’s Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) has instructed all e-commerce platforms to take necessary steps to ensure their platforms do not engage in deceptive and unfair trade practices. 

  • Although much of the ICO’s published enforcement has focused on illegal marketing calls or consent records, the framework these operate within gives the regulator scope to tackle UX practices that mislead users or undermine valid consent.

  • The ICO fined HelloFresh £140,000 for misleading marketing and failing to present clear and specific consent to users, including via a consent tick-box that lacked clarity and bundled rights. 

 

Assessing Ethical Design

 

To avoid harmful UX practices in your business, ask yourself:

  • Autonomy: Are users truly free to make choices based on their preferences?
  • Agency: Can users take desired actions easily, without coercion?
  • Transparency: Is relevant information about their choices clear, accessible, and objective?
  • Honesty: Are there misleading elements that could create false beliefs?
  • Fairness: Does the design prioritise business gains at the user's expense?

Transparency and respect for user autonomy should be the foundation of every business that has an online presence, and by addressing these questions you can create ethical, user-friendly experiences that cultivate trust in your company. Designing with integrity not only reduces regulatory risk but also strengthens brand loyalty and builds lasting customer relationships.